A Review of a Few Months with the Content King: Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Was Google's choice to release two Pro models in 2024 overkill, or a statement of confidence? I am going with the latter.
Google has typically ranked third among smartphone manufacturers. For years, Samsung's Galaxy models have been faster and smoother, but Apple continues to provide the most fluid operating system experience. Then you have stiff competition from Oppo and Nothing. In recent years, however, the distinction has become more difficult to make. Google has gained traction with the Pixel series, to the point where I can definitely state that the business is running with its fruity competitors.
It's the best Android experience out there. That used to be true exclusively for software, but Google's impressive hardware advancements have proven undeniable.
And, certainly, separating the 9 Pro into two variants appears to be a confidence play. Google gained a lot of new users with the 8th generation, so it seems to reason that the corporation would experiment with innovative ways to get even more into the ecosystem. Is this confBattery justified? Find out more in our comprehensive long-term Google Pixel 9 Pro XL review.
Design
The only discernible difference between the 9 Pro and 9 Pro XL is the size of the display and battery. I examined both phones, and while my hands favor the 9 Pro, the XL is the ideal "big" size, not feeling awkward to handle but providing a dramatically different tactility at 6.8 inches. That is the same size as the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, while the iPhone 16 Pro Max is 6.7 inches.
The squared metal chassis makes the 9 Pro XL seem like a tablet in your hands, more like an Apple than a Galaxy—if we're playing the comparison game. Several folks have mistaken this for an iPhone when they see it from the front.
However, when viewed from the rear, it is clear that this is an Apple product. Google loves the modern design of the camera, and I think it fits well with a curving, pill-like horizontal strip instead of Apple's camera square. It makes the build feel more upscale and advanced while moving away from Google's characteristic horizontal strip.
Smartphone makers are continuously looking for methods to incorporate more sustainability into the manufacturing process while maintaining a premium appearance. It's astounding when you consider the 9 Pro XL's overall design, which features a 100% recyclable aluminum outer frame and Gorilla Glass Victus 2 on both the front and back panels. The mix between a very protective design and one that readily meets all aesthetic standards is excellent, even if Google has avoided using lightweight titanium to stay up with the competition.
Google hasn't skimped on this panel. The lovely display has a big increase in maximum brightness to 1198 nits, and I didn't detect any shifting or distortion at all. In bright surroundings, I was able to watch material without strain. The 1-120Hz variable resolution rate pairs well with the Super Actua OLED display, providing a stunning visual experience that doesn't clog up even with more data-intensive apps like CapCut, everyone's favorite video editor.
The body features a solid metal frame and a glass back; however, I recommend using this with a case. The shiny coating tends to attract a lot of fingerprints.
Performance
The Pixel 9 Pro XL is powered by Google's Tensor G4 CPU and has 16GB of RAM. This combination provides a smooth and responsive experience when multitasking or running demanding apps. During my time testing the phone in Chicago, I used it to navigate the city's huge public transportation system, stream music, and edit images while on the fly. There was no perceptible latency. The Pixel handled everything smoothly, with no slowdowns, which is a significant improvement over the 8 Pro.
However, it's worth mentioning that the device warmed up during lengthy 8K video recording sessions, so I avoided them. While not a deal breaker, it is something to be aware of if you want to use the camera frequently. In terms of storage, the base model has 128GB, which may feel insufficient considering the massive file sizes of 8K films and high-resolution images. For power users, choosing the greater storage options is a sensible decision.
Camera
The camera setup on the Pixel 9 Pro XL is nothing short of spectacular. Especially with video. It has a triple-lens setup: a 50MP primary sensor, a 48MP ultra-wide lens, and a 48MP telephoto lens with 5x optical zoom. This adaptable array enabled me to record a wide range of images, but I found it especially useful for architecture. The iPhone 16 Pro does not pick up on details as well as this, which I believe is due to Google's continuously enhanced post-production process.
However, there are several outstanding difficulties. Shadows are effectively heightened, which might interfere with contrast while shooting in more diverse lighting conditions. I've been frustrated on more than a few occasions, but Google's fixes work great.
The 'Add Me' function is a remarkable feature, allowing you to snap a shot and then effortlessly replace yourself into it. This was especially beneficial for solitary travel, allowing me to participate in group shots without handing up my phone to others. It's not quite there if you want images to seem completely natural, but its advancements cannot be overlooked.
Low-light performance has also improved significantly. Capturing the neon shine of Tokyo's streets at night produced crisp, vivid photos with little noise. The 42MP front-facing camera captures vivid, well-exposed selfies.
For videographers and social media users, the improved Pan mode is a game changer. I'd say it's my favorite video feature when filming for content right now, outperforming both Samsung and Apple in terms of smooth, stable recordings that look fantastic in any lighting condition. Surprisingly, it appears even better at night, with video Night Mode capable of capturing subtleties that the iPhone 16 Pro cannot.
Pan mode was introduced a few generations ago, but it has never been more useful than now. The camera's enhancements imply that these slow, steady pans seem cinematic and constant. This is especially useful for TikTok and Instagram Reels makers, who can now create professional-quality films without the need for additional stabilizers.
Battery
Battery life is important for travelers, and the Pixel 9 Pro XL does not disappoint. With a 5,060mAh battery, it easily survived a full day of intense use. When compared to the 4700mAh capacity in the 9 Pro, Google just needed to incorporate a processor capable of making legitimate promises about energy saving.
I nailed it.
The battery life is the single finest feature of the XL, and it easily outlasts any phone I currently possess, including the iPhone 16 Pro.
When it came time to recharge, the 37W rapid charging option was a pleasant addition. I was able to charge up to 70% in about 30 minutes, which was really useful during brief pauses while exploring. In addition, the smartphone offers fast and reverse wireless charging, allowing me to charge my wireless earphones while on the road.
AI Features
Google's Gemini AI is tightly embedded into the Pixel 9 Pro XL, improving the user experience in significant ways. However, it has yet to reach its full potential. Planning my agenda while traveling became easy; I could just say, "Hey Google, draft an itinerary for a day in Shinjuku," and get a personalized plan replete with restaurant choices and tourist sites. Good ones, too.
The AI's image-generation abilities are equally impressive. For example, I was able to create graphics based on certain prompts, which was useful for envisioning various travel scenarios. Translation capabilities are extensive, allowing for real-time transcription and translation of conversations—a lifesaver while managing language obstacles in Tokyo.
Value
The Pixel 9 Pro XL, priced at $1,699, is positioned in the market's premium sector. The premium above the basic Pixel 9 Pro includes a larger display and a larger battery, which are important enhancements for power users and travelers. But, aside from the larger battery, you're spending a few hundred extra for essentially the same phone.
I believe this is Google's greatest phone to date. And, while I prefer the smaller form factor of the 9 itself, I'm delighted Google has given two sizes this generation, vying hard with the iPhone 16 Pro Max.
In my perspective, 2024 was Google's year; therefore, I'm hoping that this inspires Apple and Samsung to boost their game in 2025.