Home windows 11's fashionable context menu falls into the identical litter entice as Home windows 10
A brand new Home windows 11 replace makes the fashionable context menu extra cluttered, just like the Home windows 10 model. It provides choices like ‘Edit with Paint’ outdoors the ‘Open with’ menu, which makes us surprise: what was the purpose of the fashionable context menu if it was simply going to get bloated?
Along with the Begin menu and taskbar, one of many causes folks hated Home windows 11 when it got here out was the context menu. With Home windows 11, Microsoft changed the basic context menu with a contemporary model that takes up more room, follows Fluent Design, and was purported to be extra compact.
After Home windows 11 Construct 27744, Home windows Newest and different folks observed that there’s a brand new entry for “Edit with Paint” within the context menu.
For the reason that fashionable context menu is already enormous when it comes to measurement, modifications like this are simply noticeable as a result of they add more room to it.
And when you click on “Present extra choices”, you’ll additionally spot the identical choices as a result of they share the frequent supply:
As you may see within the above screenshots, the fashionable context menu has an issue.
It now shows choices like “Edit with Paint,” “Edit in Notepad,” and “Edit with Clipchamp” straight as a substitute of grouping them beneath the “Open with” choice. It additionally appears unclear if Microsoft is doing this deliberately as a result of we don't see third-party apps getting their very own area.
Microsoft’s strategy to exposing its apps straight through the context menu contributes to the litter, as these choices may have been positioned throughout the “Open with” submenu.
The irony is that decreasing litter was one of many causes behind killing off the basic context menu in favour of the fashionable design.
In Home windows 10, for instance, context menu would usually get fairly prolonged and take full display screen view in some instances. Microsoft stated it might deal with these considerations with the redesign of the context menu, however that doesn’t appear to be the case anymore.
In actual fact, it’s the other as a result of not solely the brand new context menu is now cluttered, but in addition slower than the basic model. On Suggestions Hub, many have complained that the context menu takes longer than ordinary to point out up.
Typically, it additionally renders damaged with choices spreading out of the allotted area. This has been noticed after Home windows 11 24H2.
Home windows Newest has additionally noticed efficiency points with these menus. Whereas the fashionable menu has gotten so much quicker over the previous few years, it’s nonetheless not that near the efficiency of the Home windows 10 context menu on low-end {hardware}.
When it comes to design, Home windows 11’s fashionable context menu is considerably higher and appears “fashionable” because of the Fluent clear background, rounded corners, and softer visuals.
However will the corporate ever get the efficiency and litter points proper?